This isn’t a bug - the model picker was redesigned in a recent update. Instead of listing each reasoning level as a separate entry (GPT-5.5 Medium, GPT-5.5 High, GPT-5.5 Extra High), models are now grouped by family.
To use GPT-5.5 at High or Extra High reasoning:
Select GPT-5.5 from the model dropdown
Hover over the model name and click Edit
Adjust the Reasoning parameter to High or Extra High
The models are still fully available - they’re just accessed through the reasoning parameter now.
I have to say this is really poorly designed UI. There are no prompts at all when selecting models, and I’ve been looking for ages with no clue how to adjust the settings.