Hey, thanks for the report.
This is a known issue. When an OpenAI API key is enabled, it can be incorrectly applied to all models, so Gemini, Claude, and other subscription models may not work.
Workaround: Turn off the OpenAI API key toggle when you want to use other models (Gemini, Claude), and turn it back on only for OpenAI models. You can use the shortcut Cmd+Shift+0 to toggle it quickly.
Related threads: