Cmd + Click on a filename in iTerm2 on Mac doesn't open Cursor as you'd expect

By setting the default app for certain file extensions, I was able to get Cmd + Click in iTerm2 to open the file up in Cursor. However, it opens a new window. I’d like it to open the file in my current Cursor window so I have the file in the context of the project/directory. This is how VSCode works.